We represent decentralized autonomous organizations | DAOs | in all matters, including bylaws with on-chain governance mechanisms, with a focus on emerging technologies in decentralized finance (DeFi), tokens, NFTs, and crypto projects.
Decentralized Autonomous Organizations (DAOs) are one of the most significant innovations introduced by blockchain technology. A DAO is a form of organization represented by rules encoded as a computer program that is transparent, controlled by the organization members, and not influenced by a central government. Since DAO's are fully or quasi-autonomous organizations, and governance, control, and often entire organizational structures are hard coded into smart contracts, the legal implications of DAO formation, governance, and implementation are critical.
A key legal issue facing DAOs relates to their legal status and structure. In the traditional world of corporations, partnerships, and limited liability companies, there are clear guidelines established by state law on how to form, govern, and manage such entities. These laws provide an overarching structure that not only defines the organization's relationship with the state but also gives potential investors, employees, and customers a clear understanding of the organization's responsibilities and legal obligations.
DAOs, however, exist in an entirely different realm, one governed by code rather than legal jurisdictions. This puts DAOs in a gray area as there is currently no legal framework specifically designed to accommodate such organizations. Several questions arise in this context: Can a DAO incorporate? Can it enter into contracts or own property? How does a DAO protect its assets and rights? And perhaps more importantly, who is held accountable when a DAO violates laws or regulations, intentionally or not? These questions illustrate the ambiguity of DAOs under the existing legal frameworks and may vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, or state to state.
Without definitive laws to guide them, DAOs operate in a legal vacuum that can make their operations risky and unpredictable. Because of this, it is of paramount importance that anyone involved in a DAO understands the potential legal implications and risks. A comprehensive understanding of both the technology and the applicable laws can greatly mitigate these risks. Despite the lack of specific laws, existing legal principles and structures can often be applied in ways that provide at least some level of legal certainty.
This unprecedented intersection of law and technology makes for a complex and often confusing landscape, where the need for expert guidance is more critical than ever. It's crucial to work with legal advisors who understand the complexities of both traditional legal structures and the unique challenges presented by DAOs. With such guidance, it is possible to navigate these uncharted waters and harness the full potential of DAOs while minimizing legal risks and uncertainties.
Understanding the rights and obligations of members within a DAO is another critical issue. In traditional organizations, these rights and obligations are defined in a charter or articles of incorporation and bylaws. In DAOs, they are often embedded in the DAO’s smart contract code. It's crucial to comprehend how this code translates to responsibilities, rights, and potential liabilities.
Regulatory compliance is also crucial for DAOs, especially given their decentralized and often transnational nature. Depending on the DAO's operations, they may need to comply with securities laws, Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and Know Your Customer (KYC) regulations, and data privacy requirements, among others. Securities laws are also a consideration for a DAO seeking to raise investors funds, release a governance token, or conduct airdrops of tokens or NFTs which hold voting power within the DAO.
Lastly, DAOs must consider how to handle disputes or disagreements within the organization. Traditional organizations rely on the court system and contractual dispute resolution provisions. However, DAOs are still in their early stages, and legal systems are still grappling with how to handle disputes involving blockchain-based entities.
Goldstein Law has been at the forefront of this technological revolution since 2017, and is helping shape the law by developing novel legal architecture for DAO bylaws and procedures guided by a detailed understanding of decentralized systems. We advise on a range of DAO-related issues, including the legal implications of DAO formation and operation, regulatory compliance, and the management of legal risks. We have represented dozens or hundreds of projects just like yours, and our attorneys can help your organization navigate the regulatory requirements and mitigate potential legal risks, without sacrificing the opportunity to build something big.
"Goldstein Law helps us navigate a difficult regulatory environment that is constantly changing. We are very happy with their work."
"We hired Goldstein Law to write terms and conditions for our NFT project and build our DAO. Jeremy really understands blockchain and web3."
"Having Jeremy by my side has been a game-changer! He understands innovation in my industry, has helped me with fundraising, and kept my business compliant.
"What sets this law firm apart is their ability to take complex issues and distill them into understandable advice. As a founder, this has made my life much easier."
"I run a short-term rental company with over 100 properties and hired Jeremy as our corporate council. He goes above and beyond for our team."
We are available by phone, chat, video or email.
Trusted corporate and transactional attorneys for technology startups.
1312 17th Street, Suite #1646
Denver, CO 80202